Knives & cutting

We earn a commission when you buy through some links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Victorinox SwissEssential · $48Good
Victorinox SwissA light, sharp everyday knife with a grip that holds even when wet.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Global ClassicUpgrade · $112Better
Global ClassicCleaner, finer cuts on delicate herbs that the Essential left bruised.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
MAC ProfessionalAbsolute · $160Best
MAC ProfessionalGreat results on tough produce where the Essential struggled.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
OXO Good Grips UtilityEssential · $21Good
OXO Good Grips UtilityA nonslip plastic board with a juice groove that goes in the dishwasher.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
John Boos Chop-N-SliceUpgrade · $87Better
John Boos Chop-N-SliceA wood board that lasts decades with oiling, not a couple of years.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Boardsmith MapleAbsolute · $270Best
Boardsmith MapleNo deep gashes and a still-straight profile after three years of use.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
OXO GoodEssential · $22Good
OXO GoodSturdy serrated shears that grip and cut through tough foods and packaging.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Misen ScissorsUpgrade · $34Better
Misen ScissorsDelicate herb cuts without the bruising the Essential's serrations can cause.See it at MisenWhy this one ›
Shun ClassicAbsolute · $60Best
Shun ClassicPoultry bone cuts that match spring-loaded poultry shears, where the Essential struggles slightly.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
VictorinoxEssential · $8Good
VictorinoxA light, sharp paring knife for peeling, hulling and coring in hand.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Global ClassicUpgrade · $59Better
Global ClassicAn edge that stayed sharp through months of testing, while the Victorinox dulled 78%.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
WusthofAbsolute · $75Best
WusthofA slightly curved blade that makes mincing a shallot easy.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Mercer Culinary M23210Essential · $16Good
Mercer Culinary M23210A 10-inch serrated knife that slices crusty sourdough, tomatoes and soft cake cleanly.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

Shun ClassicAbsolute · $149Best
Shun ClassicA sharper edge that cuts crusty sourdough with almost no resistance and stays sharp longer.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Zwilling 4-StageEssential · $41Good
Zwilling 4-StageA pull-through sharpener with coarse and fine slots for both eastern and western knives.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.

Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon

Countertop machines

Cosori TurboBlazeEssential · $100Good
Cosori TurboBlazeA six-quart basket that crisps food quickly, with fan speeds set by each cooking mode.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

Ninja DoubleAbsolute · $210Best
Ninja DoubleTwo baskets that cook two foods at different temperatures at the same time.See it at SharkninjaWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Ninja ProfessionalEssential · $100Good
Ninja ProfessionalA full-size jar that crushes frozen loads to fine snow in seconds.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Cleanblend CommercialUpgrade · $180Better
Cleanblend CommercialFibrous greens fully liquefied with no sediment, where the Essential leaves unblended bits.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Vitamix 5200Absolute · $440Best
Vitamix 5200Fibrous ingredients liquefied even in a full jar, where the Essential struggles with big batches.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Instant Pot DuoEssential · $110Good
Instant Pot DuoA pressure cooker that also slow cooks, steams, sautes, makes yogurt and keeps food warm.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Instant Pot ProUpgrade · $170Better
Instant Pot ProSous vide water-bath cooking, which the Essential's seven functions lack.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Instant Pot Duo CrispAbsolute · $220Best
Instant Pot Duo CrispAn extra air-frying lid that turns out crisp frozen foods and tender vegetables.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Hamilton Beach 6-SpeedEssential · $28Good
Hamilton Beach 6-SpeedA six-speed mixer with a power boost button for batters and whipping.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Cuisinart PowerUpgrade · $79Better
Cuisinart PowerThe power to get through thick cookie and bread doughs the Essential finds tough.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Breville HandyAbsolute · $160Best
Breville HandyThe strength to mix thick, dense cookie dough with ease where the Essential struggles.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Hamilton Beach ElectricEssential · $152Good
Hamilton Beach ElectricA light, easy-to-lift mixer that handles heavy dough and whipping.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
KitchenAid Tilt-HeadUpgrade · $430Better
KitchenAid Tilt-HeadKneads a double batch of dough into a smooth ball, where the Essential's head bobs.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Photo soonAbsolute · $750Best
Ankarsrum OriginalHandles stiff, low-moisture doughs without moving, where the Essential's head bobs.See it at AnkarsrumWhy this one ›
Panasonic FlashXpressEssential · $150Good
Panasonic FlashXpressA compact toaster oven that toasts bread evenly and faster than any other tested.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Ninja Flip & AirUpgrade · $140Better
Ninja Flip & AirA fan and air fry mode that crisps fries and wings.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Breville Smart ProAbsolute · $270Best
Breville Smart ProA roomier chamber that fits a whole chicken or a quarter sheet pan.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Aroma HousewaresEssential · $37Good
Aroma HousewaresFluffy white and brown rice from a few clear settings, plus a quick-cook mode.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Cuckoo MicomUpgrade · $140Better
Cuckoo MicomParticularly good long-grain rice right out of the bowl.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Photo soonAbsolute · $280Best
Zojirushi Neuro Fuzzy & WarmerExcellent rice in large batches, where the Essential's turned gummy and mushy.See it at StoreWhy this one ›
Hamilton Beach WithEssential · $70Good
Hamilton Beach WithA food processor that chops, slices and shreds, with a built-in bowl scraper.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
KitchenAidUpgrade · $180Better
KitchenAidSix slicing thicknesses, from thick cuts to paper-thin slices.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Cuisinart CustomAbsolute · $250Best
Cuisinart CustomKneading pizza dough on its own, with no hands-on help or creeping across the counter.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

Store, clean up & safety

Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
OXO GoodEssential · $47Good
OXO GoodDish rack that folds flat to under two inches for cabinet storage.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
KitchenAid Full-SizeUpgrade · $53Better
KitchenAid Full-SizeA drain board that sends water into the sink, so dishes dry fully overnight.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Simplehuman SteelAbsolute · $100Best
Simplehuman SteelPlate wires spaced to hold thick stoneware upright, plus a dedicated stemware rack.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Photo soonEssential · $20Good
Waterdrop PT-07BHands-free filling and a filter that can last up to 200 gallons.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Photo soonUpgrade · $41Better
Brita Water Pitcher DispenserLowers chlorine from 1.2 to 0.1 ppm and shows real filter use.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Clearly Filtered P-V3Absolute · $110Best
Clearly Filtered P-V3Broad removal of PFAS, lead, fluoride, and microplastics, with a long-lasting filter.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon

Pots & pans

Tramontina SkilletEssential · $35Good
Tramontina SkilletA light 10-inch aluminum nonstick pan that releases eggs and cooks evenly.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
OXO CeramicUpgrade · $70Better
OXO CeramicA pan that also works on induction cooktops.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Made In CookwareAbsolute · $149Best
Made In CookwareA slicker surface that lets eggs slide off without oil.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
LodgeEssential · $23Good
LodgeAn even-heating skillet that sears meats and releases baked goods cleanly.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Lodge BlacklockUpgrade · $60Better
Lodge BlacklockAbout a pound lighter to lift and easier to maneuver than the Essential.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Photo soonAbsolute · $165Best
Field CompanyCleaner food release than the Essential, from seared meats to baked goods.See it at FieldcompanyWhy this one ›
Chicago Metallic Commercial IIEssential · $25Good
Chicago Metallic Commercial IIAn uncoated aluminized steel pan that browns evenly and resists warping.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

Nordic Ware NaturalsAbsolute · $35Best
Nordic Ware NaturalsA lighter aluminum pan that is easier to lift with one hand.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Cuisinart MultiCladEssential · $280Good
Cuisinart MultiCladEven heating across a full range of pots, pans and a steamer insert.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
All-Clad D3 7-PieceUpgrade · $580Better
All-Clad D3 7-PieceGood heat retention at high heat, where the Essential's thinner base can get too hot.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
All-Clad D3 10-PieceAbsolute · $800Best
All-Clad D3 10-PieceMore even heating and less sticking than the Essential.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Lodge EnameledEssential · $90Good
Lodge EnameledAn enameled cast-iron pot that browns, braises and bakes bread with an even crust.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
CarawayUpgrade · $139Better
CarawayA lightweight pot of about 6 pounds to lift, against the Essential's over 13.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Le Creuset RoundAbsolute · $313Best
Le Creuset RoundA pot about 3 pounds lighter than the Essential, easier to lift when full.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
TramontinaEssential · $41Good
TramontinaAn even-heating everyday saucepan that is easy to lift and pour with one hand.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.

TramontinaEssential · $40Good
TramontinaEven, fast heating that browns meat and fish and sautes vegetables.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

Pyrex DeepEssential · $28Good
Pyrex DeepA deep glass baking dish with a lid that bakes evenly and handles the dishwasher.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

Great JonesAbsolute · $105Best
Great JonesA ceramic dish that can go briefly under the broiler, which the Essential's glass cannot.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Made InEssential · $249Good
Made InWide, balanced stockpot that carries comfortably when full and pours cleanly.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

Coffee & tea

Cuisinart PerfecTempEssential · $117Good
Cuisinart PerfecTempBig pots of hot coffee with strength control and a 24-hour timer.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickSome candidates were set aside.

Technivorm Moccamaster KBGVAbsolute · $369Best
Technivorm Moccamaster KBGVMore flavorful coffee, which a tasting panel rated significantly better than most machines make.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Fellow Stagg EKGEssential · $200Good
Fellow Stagg EKGAn electric gooseneck kettle that heats water to a temperature you set by the degree.See it at FellowproductsWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

Prep & measuring

Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
ThermoWorks ThermoPop 2Essential · $47Good
ThermoWorks ThermoPop 2A pocket-size probe thermometer that reads temperature in two to three seconds.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

Typhur InstaProbeAbsolute · Sold outBest
Typhur InstaProbeReadings in under one second within half a degree, versus two to three seconds.Why this one ›
Cuisinart StainlessEssential · $40Good
Cuisinart StainlessDeep stainless steel bowls with snug lids that keep hand-mixer splatter in the bowl.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.

Get ItEssential · $91Good
Get ItTen tools including three spatula sizes for folding, small-batch mixing and scraping corners.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.

OXO GoodEssential · $17Good
OXO GoodA manual rotary can opener with cushioned nonslip handles and a built-in bottle opener.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Kuhn RikonUpgrade · $23Better
Kuhn RikonSide-cut lids with smooth edges instead of sharp ones.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Hamilton BeachAbsolute · $40Best
Hamilton BeachElectric, crank-free opening that still leaves smooth edges.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›
Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon
Cuisipro 4-SidedEssential · $20Good
Cuisipro 4-SidedA very sharp stainless steel box grater with four sides that all work well.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.

Bellemain Micro-PerforatedEssential · $24Good
Bellemain Micro-PerforatedA stainless steel footed colander whose tiny holes drain fast and keep orzo in.See it at AmazonWhy this one ›

No Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.

Coming soon
Coming soon
Coming soon