Knives & cutting
We earn a commission when you buy through some links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Essential · $48Good
Upgrade · $112Better
Absolute · $160BestEssentialSoft produce, herbs, meat and poultry
UpgradeThinner, cleaner ribbons of delicate herbs
AbsoluteMeat, poultry, dense produce and aromatics
Essential · Victorinox Swiss
It arrives sharp out of the box and cuts most everyday foods cleanly, from soft produce to meat and poultry. Its light weight and rounded spine make it easy to use for long stretches without tiring the wrist. The textured handle grips securely even with wet hands, and the blade sharpens easily.
Pro: A light, sharp everyday knife with a grip that holds even when wet.
Con: The softer edge dulls faster, and dense foods take extra pressure.
Upgrade · Global Classic
A thin, very sharp blade on a light body makes it nimble for fine slicing and delicate mincing. The blade and hollow handle are one piece of steel, weighted with sand for balance, with no seams to trap food. It stays sharp with little upkeep and moves easily through aromatics, poultry and soft produce.
Pro: Cleaner, finer cuts on delicate herbs that the Essential left bruised.
Con: Its all-steel handle can turn slippery when wet, and dense foods take extra force.
Absolute · MAC Professional
A thin, very sharp blade is curved enough for rocking yet straight enough for push-pull chopping. Dimples along the blade help keep sticky foods from clinging, and the light, balanced build is easy on hands and wrists. It holds its edge for a long time, needing a whetstone only about once a year.
Pro: Great results on tough produce where the Essential struggled.
Con: The hard, thin edge can chip on very hard foods and rusts if left wet.
Essential · $21Good
Upgrade · $87Better
Absolute · $270BestEssentialMeat juices and produce
UpgradeCut large foods without moving pieces aside
AbsoluteResists deep cuts, heals itself
Essential · OXO Good Grips Utility
A plastic board about 15 by 10 inches, sized for everyday prep. Silicone strips on the short sides help hold it in place on the counter. One side has a groove that catches meat juices, and the other is flat. The nonporous surface keeps odors at bay, and it can go in the dishwasher after every use.
Pro: A nonslip plastic board with a juice groove that goes in the dishwasher.
Con: It wears out within a couple of years, and knives slide on its slick surface.
Upgrade · John Boos Chop-N-Slice
A thick, reversible maple board with a large surface for prepping several ingredients at once. Its weight holds it in place on the counter without nonslip features, and you can flip it between tasks. It takes a beating from knives yet stays soft enough to spare the edge, and it can be sanded if the surface roughens.
Pro: A wood board that lasts decades with oiling, not a couple of years.
Con: It is heavy, must be washed by hand, and has no juice groove.
Absolute · Boardsmith Maple
An end-grain maple board on feet that keep it firmly in place during hard chopping and let it dry underneath. The surface resists deep cuts, heals itself and is soft enough to keep knives sharp. It needs regular oiling, and juice and finger grooves can be added.
Pro: No deep gashes and a still-straight profile after three years of use.
Con: It is big and heavy, which makes it hard to clean.
Essential · $22Good
Upgrade · $34Better
Absolute · $60BestEssentialSlippery tough foods, woody stems
UpgradeDelicate herbs without bruising
AbsoluteSharpest cuts on bulky packaging
Essential · OXO Good
Micro-serrated blades grip slippery and tough foods, cutting through meat, skin and woody herb stems. Spacious, cushioned handles with an opening of about 2.75 inches stayed comfortable and kept hands from slipping, even when oily. The 4-inch blades come apart for cleaning, and a built-in stripper pulls leaves off herb stems.
Pro: Sturdy serrated shears that grip and cut through tough foods and packaging.
Con: Serrated blades can bruise delicate herbs and catch on paper.
Upgrade · Misen Scissors
Long 5-inch blades and extra-wide handles suit larger hands and long, even cuts such as breaking down larger poultry. Micro-serrated edges grab slippery skin, while pointed, sharp tips make quick, precise snips. Silicone-lined handles add grip, and the shears felt light for their size.
Pro: Delicate herb cuts without the bruising the Essential's serrations can cause.
Con: Handles can feel flimsy and hard to control for smaller hands.
Absolute · Shun Classic
One straight blade and one finely serrated blade make it versatile, and the blades felt razor-sharp. Thin, nimble blades with tapered tips make precise snips and move around bones and joints easily. Built-in extras include a bottle opener, nutcracker and bone breaker, and the blades come apart for cleaning.
Pro: Poultry bone cuts that match spring-loaded poultry shears, where the Essential struggles slightly.
Con: Takes extra force through tough items and bone, and handles may feel small.
Essential · $8Good
Upgrade · $59BetterEssentialHulling strawberries, peeling apples, shelling shrimp
UpgradeStrawberries, shallots and tomato skin
AbsolutePrecise, delicate prep, petite blade
Essential · Victorinox
Its thin, flexible, spear-point blade is good at in-hand jobs like hulling strawberries, peeling apples and shelling shrimp. It is very light, at under an ounce, and its grippy plastic handle does not slip even when wet. The 3.25-inch blade is long enough to halve medium-large apples. Its straight edge suits coring and slicing better than mincing.
Pro: A light, sharp paring knife for peeling, hulling and coring in hand.
Con: It loses sharpness over time, and its thin blade struggles with squash or potatoes.
Upgrade · Global Classic
This 3.5-inch paring knife is made from a single piece of stainless steel, with no handle joints or rivets to clean. It is light and well balanced, and reviewers needed next to no effort to hull strawberries, peel shallots and slice delicate tomato skin. It also supremed orange segments quickly.
Pro: An edge that stayed sharp through months of testing, while the Victorinox dulled 78%.
Con: Its all-metal handle can get slippery when wet or greasy.
Absolute · Wusthof
This 3.5-inch paring knife has a compact, slim handle and a petite stainless steel blade suited to precise, delicate prep. Reviewers found it sharp and well balanced, and it peeled, sliced and cut beautifully. It hulled strawberries without slipping and made a perfect apple peel and neat orange segments.
Pro: A slightly curved blade that makes mincing a shallot easy.
Con: It needed more pressure to slice through a tomato than one rival knife.
Essential · $16GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
Absolute · $149BestEssentialButternut squash and soft cake
AbsoluteCrusty baguette and sourdough
Essential · Mercer Culinary M23210
Its 10-inch serrated blade has a textured rubber-and-plastic handle that reviewers found grippy and comfortable. It sliced crusty sourdough, tomatoes, cake and even butternut squash cleanly. It is the heaviest of the tested knives at about 6 ounces but well balanced. One reviewer has used it for four years with no obvious wear.
Pro: A 10-inch serrated knife that slices crusty sourdough, tomatoes and soft cake cleanly.
Con: It is less sharp than top rivals and needs more effort on crusty loaves.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
Absolute · Shun Classic
This 9-inch serrated knife has a high-carbon VG-MAX steel core that resists dulling. It sliced tomatoes thin and crusty baguette and sourdough like butter, and soft bread fell into neat slices. Its wide, low serrations and tall blade add cutting force, and reviewers found it comfortable and well balanced.
Pro: A sharper edge that cuts crusty sourdough with almost no resistance and stays sharp longer.
Con: Its 9-inch blade struggles to cut across wider boules without angling the knife.
Essential · $41GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.
EssentialSoft and firm produce easily
Essential · Zwilling 4-Stage
You pull the blade heel to tip through one of four slots, coarse and fine at both 10 and 15 degrees, for Western and Japanese-style knives. It is simple to use and suits beginners, though the instructions are bare-bones. Sharpened blades came out smooth and polished with no scratches or chips, and cut soft and firm produce easily.
Pro: A pull-through sharpener with coarse and fine slots for both eastern and western knives.
Con: The grip can be hard to hold steady, even with its nonslip bottom.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. Some candidates were set aside.
Countertop machines
Essential · $100GoodNo Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · $210BestEssentialCrisping raw, frozen and chilled foods
AbsoluteSmall footprint and generous capacity
Essential · Cosori TurboBlaze
It holds 6 quarts, draws 1725 watts and heats from 90°F to 450°F. Its ten presets each set a fan speed shown on the display. It browned frozen foods evenly, kept meats juicy, left vegetables tender-crisp and crisped faster than others tested. Its basket and crisper plate are dishwasher-safe. It ran at 58 decibels at 400°F, quieter than most.
Pro: A six-quart basket that crisps food quickly, with fan speeds set by each cooking mode.
Con: Small pieces of food can fall through the crisper plate and get stuck underneath.
No Upgrade pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · Ninja Double
It stacks two five-quart baskets for 10 quarts in all, in a narrow footprint. Each basket can be programmed on its own, and a sync feature finishes both at the same time. It has six modes and reaches 450°F. Wire racks in each basket let it cook four foods at once.
Pro: Two baskets that cook two foods at different temperatures at the same time.
Con: Results can be uneven, and the interface takes time to learn.
Essential · $100Good
Upgrade · $180Better
Absolute · $440BestEssentialFast crushed ice with no chunks
UpgradeFully liquefied fibrous greens, no sediment
AbsoluteGentle starts for hot liquids
Essential · Ninja Professional
This 1,000-watt blender has a 72-ounce jar, three speeds and a pulse button. Its removable blade spins up the center, so ingredients cannot hide under it. It made dips and nut butter and crushed frozen loads without water, the blade never sticking. Suction cups hold the base steady, and the lid pours through a spout.
Pro: A full-size jar that crushes frozen loads to fine snow in seconds.
Con: It leaves unblended bits in fibrous ingredients, especially in bigger batches.
Upgrade · Cleanblend Commercial
This 1,800-watt blender has a 64-ounce jar, speed dial, pulse switch and tamper. Its smoothies were among the smoothest tested, with hardly any seeds left after straining. It crushed frozen loads for drinks and made an even emulsified dressing in seconds. The jar is hand-wash only. Its motor held up through five years of regular use.
Pro: Fibrous greens fully liquefied with no sediment, where the Essential leaves unblended bits.
Con: Its lowest speed still starts fast, sending hot liquid up to the lid.
Absolute · Vitamix 5200
It has a tall, tapered 64-ounce jar, a 10-speed dial, a high-speed switch and a tamper. Its jar shape and strong motor form a vortex that pulls ingredients down into the blades. It smoothly blended nuts into butter and can heat ingredients through friction alone. Its lowest speed starts slowly, so hot liquid is less likely to shoot up.
Pro: Fibrous ingredients liquefied even in a full jar, where the Essential struggles with big batches.
Con: At over 20 inches tall, it will not fit under many standard cabinets.
Essential · $110Good
Upgrade · $170Better
Absolute · $220BestEssentialGrain cooked tender rather than mushy
UpgradeSous vide water-bath cooking
AbsoluteCrisp frozen foods and tender vegetables
Essential · Instant Pot Duo
It pressure cooks, slow cooks, steams, sautes, makes yogurt and keeps food warm. Two pressure settings, high and low, give more control over delicate foods, which may help keep them from overcooking. It comes in 3, 6 and 8 quart sizes, and the inner pot is stainless steel. Its detachable cord suits storing it in a tight cabinet.
Pro: A pressure cooker that also slow cooks, steams, sautes, makes yogurt and keeps food warm.
Con: Pressure took a long time to release naturally.
Upgrade · Instant Pot Pro
It pressure cooks, slow cooks, steams, sautes, makes yogurt, sterilizes and cooks sous vide, with 28 presets and five savable custom programs. Its stainless steel inner pot has handles and works on stovetops and in the oven. Saute heat has five levels, and a switch releases steam quickly and safely. It comes in 6 and 8 quart sizes.
Pro: Sous vide water-bath cooking, which the Essential's seven functions lack.
Con: The many settings and buttons can overwhelm a beginner.
Absolute · Instant Pot Duo Crisp
It pressure cooks, slow cooks, steams, sautes and cooks sous vide under one lid, and air fries, roasts, bakes, broils and dehydrates under a second. The unit senses which lid is on. It holds 8 quarts in a stainless steel inner pot and also comes in a 6-quart size. The pot and pressure lid can go in the dishwasher.
Pro: An extra air-frying lid that turns out crisp frozen foods and tender vegetables.
Con: It builds pressure more slowly than most, and the lower basket layer crisps less.
Essential · $28Good
Upgrade · $79Better
Absolute · $160BestEssentialPower for batters and whipping
UpgradeThick cookie and bread doughs
AbsoluteThick batters without struggle
Essential · Hamilton Beach 6-Speed
It has six speeds, a 250-watt motor and a boost button that adds power at any speed. It whipped cream easily and made smooth batter. Its back rests on the edge of the bowl so the beaters do not drip, and a snap-on case holds the attachments. Its handle was comfortable to hold.
Pro: A six-speed mixer with a power boost button for batters and whipping.
Con: It struggles to mix thick, dense doughs thoroughly and has no dough hooks.
Upgrade · Cuisinart Power
It has nine speeds changed with touch buttons, a 220-watt motor and a digital screen showing the speed. It comes with beaters, a whisk, two dough hooks and a spatula, all stored in a snap-on case. It handled thick doughs and its whisk made stiff peaks in under two minutes.
Pro: The power to get through thick cookie and bread doughs the Essential finds tough.
Con: It runs loud at its top speeds, louder than most other mixers tested.
Absolute · Breville Handy
It has nine speeds on a scroll wheel, a pause button and a count-up timer. A light shines into the bowl, and rubber-coated beaters run quietly and scrape the sides of the bowl. It senses which attachment is fitted and adjusts its speed range. It comes with two beaters, two whisks and two dough hooks in a snap-on case.
Pro: The strength to mix thick, dense cookie dough with ease where the Essential struggles.
Con: It is heavier than most hand mixers and can tire the hand over long mixing.
Essential · $152Good
Upgrade · $430BetterEssentialHeavy dough and whipping
UpgradeChunky batter and smooth dough
AbsoluteStiff, low-moisture doughs without moving
Essential · Hamilton Beach Electric
A 4-quart tilt-head mixer weighing under 10 pounds, with a top handle for carrying from cabinet to counter. It kneads dough evenly, whips to stiff peaks and holds speed with thick, heavy mixtures. Seven speeds, a splash guard and dishwasher-safe attachments come with it.
Pro: A light, easy-to-lift mixer that handles heavy dough and whipping.
Con: Its head bobs and rattles under heavy dough, and starts can splatter.
Upgrade · KitchenAid Tilt-Head
A 5-quart tilt-head mixer with a 325-watt motor, 10 speeds and a bowl with a handle. It whipped, combined and kneaded reliably, evenly and thoroughly. It can beat chunky batter and knead a double batch of dough into a smooth ball. A front hub takes more than 10 attachments sold separately, and the bowl and attachments are dishwasher safe.
Pro: Kneads a double batch of dough into a smooth ball, where the Essential's head bobs.
Con: It wobbles at high speed or when full, and weighs nearly 23 pounds.
Absolute · Ankarsrum Original
A mixer with its motor in the base that spins the bowl, with a 7-quart bowl, 600-watt motor, speed dial and timer. It comes with a dough roller, scraper and hook, plus a smaller second bowl with whisks for whipping and batters. It stayed still through heavy kneading and whipped to stiff peaks in 35 seconds.
Pro: Handles stiff, low-moisture doughs without moving, where the Essential's head bobs.
Con: It takes time to learn, has many parts to store, and its bowls lack handles.
Essential · $150Good
Absolute · $270BestEssentialEven golden toast in batches
UpgradeCrispy fries and wings
AbsoluteBroiled chicken breasts that look grilled
Essential · Panasonic FlashXpress
This compact toaster oven measures 13 by 12 by 10.25 inches and fits four slices of toast or a 9-inch pizza. It toasted bread to an even golden-brown medium in two and a half minutes. Presets cover toast, frozen waffles, rolls, frozen pizza, frozen hash browns and reheating leftovers. The rack slides out when the door opens.
Pro: A compact toaster oven that toasts bread evenly and faster than any other tested.
Con: It has no fan for air frying or convection baking, and holds only one rack.
Upgrade · Ninja Flip & Air
This air fryer toaster oven flips up onto its back edge to free counter space between uses. Its wide chamber fits an 11-inch pizza or six slices of bread. Its eight functions are air fry, air roast, air broil, bake, bagel, toast, dehydrate and keep warm. In side-by-side tests, it always beeped first during preheating.
Pro: A fan and air fry mode that crisps fries and wings.
Con: Its low ceiling rules out bulky foods like a whole chicken and makes cleaning harder.
Absolute · Breville Smart Pro
This convection toaster oven fits up to six slices of bread and a 13-inch pizza. It is spacious enough for larger items like a whole chicken or a quarter sheet pan. Its 10 functions are toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, warm and slow cook. Three dials set function, temperature and time.
Pro: A roomier chamber that fits a whole chicken or a quarter sheet pan.
Con: It is quite large for a countertop, and its convection fan is loud.
Essential · $37GoodEssentialFluffy rice and steaming food
UpgradeLong-grain rice and soak time
AbsolutePorridge and three white rice textures
Essential · Aroma Housewares
It holds 4 cups of uncooked rice, about 8 cups cooked, sized for individuals, couples or smaller families. Several kinds of rice came out fluffy and evenly cooked, and a display counts down the remaining cooking time. It switches to keep-warm on its own when cooking ends, and the pot and paddle can go in the dishwasher.
Pro: Fluffy white and brown rice from a few clear settings, plus a quick-cook mode.
Con: Large batches of long-grain rice turned gummy, and some parts felt flimsy.
Upgrade · Cuckoo Micom
It holds 6 cups of uncooked rice, 12 cups cooked, with 11 menu options including brown rice and porridge. You can set how long rice soaks, how hot it gets and how long it cooks. An auto-clean mode uses steam to loosen stuck food in 25 minutes.
Pro: Particularly good long-grain rice right out of the bowl.
Con: The lid springs open hard enough to rock the unit, risking a blast of steam.
Absolute · Zojirushi Neuro Fuzzy & Warmer
It holds 5.5 cups of uncooked rice, about 10 cups cooked, and adjusts time and temperature as the rice cooks. Presets cover white rice in three textures, brown rice, porridge and a quick mode. Handles on the inner pot and a retractable cord make serving and storage easier.
Pro: Excellent rice in large batches, where the Essential's turned gummy and mushy.
Con: Cooking is slow: white rice took 48 minutes, brown rice nearly two hours.
Essential · $70Good
Upgrade · $180Better
Absolute · $250BestEssentialSlicing or shredding, with bowl scraper
UpgradeSix slicing thicknesses, thick to paper-thin
AbsoluteKneading pizza dough on its own
Essential · Hamilton Beach With
A 450-watt motor and a two-level dial run one blade and one reversible disc for slicing or shredding. A three-pronged scraper turns with a knob to clear the bowl's sides, so you open the lid less. Setup is easy, and the dial is simple to use.
Pro: A food processor that chops, slices and shreds, with a built-in bowl scraper.
Con: It is very loud, and its scraper misses the bottom inch of the bowl.
Upgrade · KitchenAid
It has a 13-cup bowl, a 500-watt motor and low, high and pulse settings. It comes with a multipurpose blade, adjustable slicing disc, reversible shredding disc and dough blade, all stored in a caddy inside the bowl. The bowl snaps on without twisting, and the lid hinges shut.
Pro: Six slicing thicknesses, from thick cuts to paper-thin slices.
Con: Its feed tube is small, so large tomatoes and potatoes need cutting first.
Absolute · Cuisinart Custom
It has a 14-cup bowl, a 720-watt motor and just two paddle buttons, one for on and one for off or pulse. It comes with an S-blade, a slicing disc and a shredding disc, and the parts are dishwasher-safe. Reviewers found it quiet while running.
Pro: Kneading pizza dough on its own, with no hands-on help or creeping across the counter.
Con: Assembly is fussy, and at about 18 pounds it is heavy to lift.
Store, clean up & safety
Essential · $47Good
Upgrade · $53Better
Absolute · $100BestEssentialPlate slots and drip tray
UpgradeCapacity and fully loaded stability
AbsoluteSwivel spout drains into sink
Essential · OXO Good
This aluminum and plastic rack has an upper level with plate slots and a ridged drip tray below that keeps glasses and pots raised. Folded, it lies flat and works as a drying mat. The tray has no spout, but water pours cleanly from its corners.
Pro: Dish rack that folds flat to under two inches for cabinet storage.
Con: Tall glasses and stemware do not fit well upright.
Upgrade · KitchenAid Full-Size
This large stainless steel rack holds four place settings plus a 10-inch skillet, and can stand sheet trays and cutting boards upright. Its angled drainboard sends water into the sink, and a clip-on utensil holder frees space for dishes. It needs room on the counter, since it has to sit at its widest orientation.
Pro: A drain board that sends water into the sink, so dishes dry fully overnight.
Con: Stemware has no secure upright spot, so tall glasses can tip.
Absolute · Simplehuman Steel
This stainless steel rack held dinner settings for four, a 10-inch skillet and a Dutch oven with its lid. It has a wine rack for up to four glasses, four cup hooks and a utensil holder divided into three sections. A swivel spout drains water into the sink however the rack is placed.
Pro: Plate wires spaced to hold thick stoneware upright, plus a dedicated stemware rack.
Con: It takes up a lot of counter space and is slow to clean.
Absolute · $110BestEssentialHands-free filling and 200 gallons
UpgradeCuts chlorine from 1.2 to 0.1 ppm
AbsoluteOver 365 contaminants, 100 gallons
Essential · Waterdrop PT-07B
This 10-cup pitcher offers hands-free filling: the door opens when the stream hits the lid. Its filter is certified to NSF/ANSI 42 and 372, reduces 15 contaminants, and can last up to 200 gallons. A bit heavy to lift when full, which some may find a drawback.
Pro: Hands-free filling and a filter that can last up to 200 gallons.
Con: A bit heavy to lift when full.
Upgrade · Brita Water Pitcher Dispenser
It is a 10-cup pitcher that fills three 24-ounce bottles, and one filter is included. Filtering cuts chlorine from 1.2 to 0.1 ppm, while TDS barely changes. The indicator light tracks real filter use, not only calendar time. Filtering is not the fastest, the main trade-off here.
Pro: Lowers chlorine from 1.2 to 0.1 ppm and shows real filter use.
Con: Filtering isn't the fastest.
Absolute · Clearly Filtered P-V3
It is a 10-cup water filter pitcher with a filter that lasts 100 gallons. It reduces over 365 contaminants, among them PFAS, lead, fluoride, and microplastics. Setup is quick: priming the filter with the included bag took under 10 minutes. Filtering is slow, needing 20 minutes or more for the upper reservoir.
Pro: Broad removal of PFAS, lead, fluoride, and microplastics, with a long-lasting filter.
Con: Filtering is slow: 20 minutes or more per upper reservoir.
Pots & pans
Essential · $35Good
Absolute · $149BestEssentialRemovable silicone handle sleeve
UpgradeBowl-like shape with more space
AbsoluteFive layers aluminum stainless steel
Essential · Tramontina Skillet
This heavy-gauge aluminum pan heats quickly and evenly, and its reinforced coating let eggs, omelettes and pancakes slide out without sticking. It weighs about 2 pounds and has flared edges and a removable silicone handle sleeve for a cool, secure grip. It is oven safe to 400°F with the sleeve on and 500°F without it.
Pro: A light 10-inch aluminum nonstick pan that releases eggs and cooks evenly.
Con: It does not work on induction cooktops.
Upgrade · OXO Ceramic
This 10-inch pan has a hard-anodized aluminum body with a diamond-reinforced ceramic coating that heats evenly and releases food easily. Its bowl-like shape gives up to 35% more cooking space, and the stainless steel handle stays cool and feels balanced. It works on all stovetops, is oven safe to 600°F and can go in the dishwasher.
Pro: A pan that also works on induction cooktops.
Con: Its nonstick was not the slickest, with minor sticking in the first couple of uses.
Absolute · Made In Cookware
It is built from five layers of aluminum and stainless steel and heats quickly, evenly and consistently. Eggs, fish and frittatas slid out without effort, and it cleans easily. It works on all cooktops including induction, is oven safe to 500°F and has a stay-cool handle.
Pro: A slicker surface that lets eggs slide off without oil.
Con: Its steep angled sides make the cooking area small, too small for several pancakes.
Essential · $23Good
Upgrade · $60BetterEssentialSearing meat and browning baked goods
UpgradeLighter and easier to maneuver
AbsoluteCleaner food release and deep crust
Essential · Lodge
It heats evenly and sears meats with beautiful crusts. Baked goods come out evenly golden and release cleanly. It arrives pre-seasoned and grows slicker the more it is used. Cleanup takes little more than warm water and a wipe. A helper handle helps carry its weight with two hands.
Pro: An even-heating skillet that sears meats and releases baked goods cleanly.
Con: Just over 5 pounds at 10.25 inches, it is hard to lift and tilt.
Upgrade · Lodge Blacklock
Slightly thinner walls make it about a pound lighter than the classic version, and it comes triple-seasoned, ready to cook. It is very nonstick, and baked goods release without sticking under a deep golden brown crust. It heats up fast and sears meats well. Cleanup needs only hot water or a wipe.
Pro: About a pound lighter to lift and easier to maneuver than the Essential.
Con: Its curved handle is hard to grip one-handed, especially in an oven mitt.
Absolute · Field Company
Its polished surface releases food neatly and is a little less likely to hold burnt bits. At about 4.5 pounds, it is lighter than most cast iron. A long handle adds leverage when carrying a full pan. It heats evenly and develops a nonstick surface after a few uses. Flared sides make pouring out fats easy without spouts.
Pro: Cleaner food release than the Essential, from seared meats to baked goods.
Con: It has no pour spouts, so liquids are more likely to spill.
Essential · $25GoodNo Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · $35BestEssentialCookies and pizza bottoms
AbsoluteGolden-brown cookies and vegetables
Essential · Chicago Metallic Commercial II
This aluminized steel pan has an uncoated surface and a rolled rim reinforced with wire rods to resist warping. Reviewers found it heated evenly, browning cookies and pizza bottoms without burning them. It is dishwasher-safe, though hand-washing is recommended. It comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
Pro: An uncoated aluminized steel pan that browns evenly and resists warping.
Con: It is a bit heavier than aluminum pans and stains with use.
No Upgrade pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · Nordic Ware Naturals
This aluminum half sheet has an encapsulated galvanized steel rim that helps prevent warping. Reviewers found it heated evenly, turning out golden-brown cookies and crisp roasted vegetables. It weighs about 1.65 pounds and is oven-safe up to 500 degrees F. It carries a lifetime warranty.
Pro: A lighter aluminum pan that is easier to lift with one hand.
Con: It scratches and stains easily and must be washed by hand.
Essential · $280Good
Upgrade · $580Better
Absolute · $800BestEssentialEven heating across a full range
UpgradeGood heat retention at high heat
AbsoluteEven browning and steady simmering
Essential · Cuisinart MultiClad
This tri-ply set heats evenly, with no hot or cool spots. It includes two saucepans, a sauté pan, a stockpot, two skillets and a steamer insert. Pieces are light and well balanced, easy to tilt and toss food in. Handles are comfortable, and high sides keep splatters in. It sears meat well and works on induction.
Pro: Even heating across a full range of pots, pans and a steamer insert.
Con: It heats fast and can run too hot, so the heat needs watching.
Upgrade · All-Clad D3 7-Piece
This tri-ply set heats evenly, holds that heat and handles high heat well. It has a frying pan, a saucepan, a sauté pan and a large stockpot, with lids. Lids fit well and handles stay cool in use. Meats and vegetables cooked evenly and flipped without sticking. It survived repeated damage tests; hand washing is advised.
Pro: Good heat retention at high heat, where the Essential's thinner base can get too hot.
Con: The pieces don't nest or stack, so storing them takes room.
Absolute · All-Clad D3 10-Piece
This tri-ply set with an aluminum core heats evenly, browns well and keeps sauces at a steady simmer. It comes with two frying pans, two saucepans of different shapes, a sauté pan and a stockpot. Pieces are light to lift, well balanced, and oven-safe to 600°F. Pans resisted scratching and their flat bottoms don't warp under high heat.
Pro: More even heating and less sticking than the Essential.
Con: The handles could be more comfortable to hold, and overheating oil left cosmetic stains.
Essential · $90Good
Upgrade · $139Better
Absolute · $313BestEssentialEven crust that held together
UpgradeProteins release easily, wiped clean
AbsoluteTight lid holds in moisture
Essential · Lodge Enameled
In bread tests it gave an even, crisp crust that held together without flaking. It heated quickly, browned meat well and braised it tender, with very good ratings for even cooking. The enamel interior needs no seasoning, stands up to acidic foods and cleans easily. Wide side handles are easy to grip with a towel or mitts.
Pro: An enameled cast-iron pot that browns, braises and bakes bread with an even crust.
Con: It weighs over 13 pounds, and its enamel rim chipped when knocked with a spoon.
Upgrade · Caraway
This ceramic-coated aluminum pot weighs about 6 pounds and has wide, roomy handles that are easy to grip in oven mitts. Its nonstick interior let proteins release easily, kept sauces from sticking and wiped clean with water and a sponge. It baked bread with an even, crisp crust and kept a steady simmer.
Pro: A lightweight pot of about 6 pounds to lift, against the Essential's over 13.
Con: It holds heat less well than cast iron, sears paler, and cannot take metal utensils.
Absolute · Le Creuset Round
This enameled cast-iron pot heated quickly, seared meat to a crusty brown and braised it tender. It cooked foods the most evenly in one test, and its tight lid holds in moisture. Wide looped handles are easy to hold even with an oven mitt. Its light interior makes browning easy to watch.
Pro: A pot about 3 pounds lighter than the Essential, easier to lift when full.
Con: Its light interior stains with use, and one test found weaker heat retention.
Essential · $41GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.
Essential · Tramontina
It heats evenly with no hot spots, and grains and sauces came out without sticking or burning. The handle stays cool, and it lifts and pours with one hand even when full of boiling liquid. Its eight-inch width lets a whisk or spoon reach into the corners. It works on induction and goes in the oven up to 500°F.
Pro: An even-heating everyday saucepan that is easy to lift and pour with one hand.
Con: Its shiny surface picks up minor water spots and smudges from washing and handling.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. Some candidates were set aside.
Essential · $40GoodNo Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
EssentialEven, fast heating for poultry
AbsoluteCrisp, golden crust on meat
Essential · Tramontina
A fully clad three-ply pan about 12 inches across, weighing about 3 pounds, oven-safe to 500°F and working on induction. It heats evenly and responds quickly to temperature changes, browning poultry evenly and cooking fish without sticking. Its rounded handle is comfortable to hold and stays secure even when gripped with a towel.
Pro: Even, fast heating that browns meat and fish and sautes vegetables.
Con: Sloped sides leave less flat cooking room, and the base can warp slightly over time.
No Upgrade pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · All-Clad D3
A three-ply pan with an aluminum core and a tight-fitting lid, oven-safe to 600°F and induction-compatible. It heats as fast as others tested, with temperature differences under 15 degrees across the surface. It sears meat and fish to a crisp, golden crust and is light enough to maneuver with one hand.
Pro: More consistent browning of poultry.
Con: Its grooved handle can dig into bare hands, and the surface stains from oil.
Essential · $28GoodNo Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · $105BestEssentialEvenly cooked baked pasta
AbsoluteEven baking and crisp edges
Essential · Pyrex Deep
This deep glass dish holds 5 quarts, with room for large batches. In tests, baked pasta came out well browned and evenly cooked, and baked goods stayed moist. Clear glass lets you watch food cook and won't absorb stains or flavors. A tight-fitting lid stores leftovers. Stacking, hand washing and dishwasher runs left it without cracks or chips.
Pro: A deep glass baking dish with a lid that bakes evenly and handles the dishwasher.
Con: Its narrow tab handles feel less secure, and it cannot go under the broiler.
No Upgrade pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · Great Jones
This ceramic dish is about three inches deep and holds roughly 4 quarts, with room to stack up layered casseroles. Large looped handles give a secure grip with oven mitts, even when it is full. It baked evenly, held heat well, and cleaned easily by hand since nothing stuck. It is also safe in the dishwasher, microwave and freezer.
Pro: A ceramic dish that can go briefly under the broiler, which the Essential's glass cannot.
Con: Metal utensils can scratch it, and two of four units in one test arrived broken.
Essential · $249GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
EssentialHeats quickly and holds its heat
Essential · Made In
This 8-quart, five-ply pot of steel and aluminum heats quickly and holds its heat. Its short, wide shape lets you reach the whole interior and see the food. Roomy, flat handles grip well with or without oven mitts, and the flared rim pours cleanly. The lid stays put and holds steam, and burnt-on food wiped off with a sponge.
Pro: Wide, balanced stockpot that carries comfortably when full and pours cleanly.
Con: Its surfaces discolored after testing, and it whined while heating on induction.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
Coffee & tea
Essential · $117GoodNo Upgrade pickSome candidates were set aside.
Absolute · $369BestEssentialStrength control and mid-brew pause
AbsolutePrecise temperature control and showerhead
Essential · Cuisinart PerfecTemp
It brews up to 14 cups, or about 70 ounces, which works out to about five to six normal mugs. It has a 24-hour timer, regular or bold strength, a 1-to-4-cup setting and a pause to pour mid-brew. The warming plate held coffee at 176°F after an hour, and the carafe and basket are dishwasher-safe.
Pro: Big pots of hot coffee with strength control and a 24-hour timer.
Con: The carafe lid must come off to pour, and small brews run weaker and cooler.
No Upgrade pick. Some candidates were set aside.
Absolute · Technivorm Moccamaster KBGV
It brews up to 10 cups, about 40 ounces, in roughly 4 to 6 minutes. A copper heating element holds water near 200°F, and a showerhead with multiple outlets wets the grounds evenly. Two switches run it, one for power and one for a half or full pot, and a hot plate keeps the glass carafe warm.
Pro: More flavorful coffee, which a tasting panel rated significantly better than most machines make.
Con: There is no timer or auto-brew, so you flip a switch to start each pot.
Essential · $200GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
EssentialPrecise temperature by the degree
Essential · Fellow Stagg EKG
A dial and an LCD screen let you set the temperature in one-degree steps and read it. It also has a hold setting and a timer. Its ergonomic handle and long, narrow spout make precise pouring easy. It holds 0.9 liters and reached a boil in under four and a half minutes.
Pro: An electric gooseneck kettle that heats water to a temperature you set by the degree.
Con: The slow flow can frustrate tea or French press, and the spout tip is sharp.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
EssentialLoose grounds fill large travel mug
UpgradeOne touch, five drink sizes
AbsoluteCovers a wide range of drinks
Essential · Ninja Combo Machine
This single-serve maker brews K-Cup pods or loose grounds, and its frother folds away when not in use. Loose grounds fill a large travel mug, brewing up to 24 ounces. Accessories store on the machine, and the control panel makes choosing a drink simple. Pods top out at 12 ounces, which limits big mugs made from pods.
Upgrade · Nespresso Vertuo Plus
This machine brews espresso shots and full coffee cups from barcoded capsules that set the brew automatically. One touch starts every drink, in five sizes from a 0.85-ounce ristretto up to 8 ounces. A removable water tank can sit at the side or back, and the bin holds up to 10 used capsules. Recycling is the trade-off: without easy UPS pickup or a drop-off point, returning capsules may be tedious.
Absolute · Bruvi BV-01
Single-serve brewer that uses its own B-Pods, with a touchscreen and app. For a pod machine, it covers a wide range of drinks, and brews each of them well. Its B-Pods are meant to break down in a landfill faster than regular pods. Pods are currently sold only online, with fewer varieties than Keurig offers.
Prep & measuring
Essential · $47GoodNo Upgrade pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · Sold outBestEssentialRead from any angle
AbsoluteReadings in under one second
Essential · ThermoWorks ThermoPop 2
Its large backlit display rotates automatically, so you can read it from any angle, even in the dark. It is accurate to about 1°F and rated IP67, so it survives a quick dunk in water. A sheath protects the rigid probe and clips to a pocket, and the battery is rated for 4,000 hours.
Pro: A pocket-size probe thermometer that reads temperature in two to three seconds.
Con: It does not turn on by itself and is slower than higher-end models.
No Upgrade pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Absolute · Typhur InstaProbe
Its OLED display shows white numbers on black that are easy to read in any light. The display rotates automatically, so it works in either hand and at any angle. It is rated IP67 waterproof and has a magnet for sticking it on the stove or fridge. It runs on two AAA batteries, which come in the box.
Pro: Readings in under one second within half a degree, versus two to three seconds.
Con: The probe point is always exposed, so you need care when reaching for it.
Essential · $40GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.
EssentialDeep bowls with snug lids
Essential · Cuisinart Stainless
A set of three stainless steel bowls in 1.5, 3 and 5 quarts, each with a snug plastic lid for storing food. Tall sides keep splashes from a hand mixer in the bowl. They are dishwasher-safe, nest for storage and can work as a double boiler, but not in the microwave.
Pro: Deep stainless steel bowls with snug lids that keep hand-mixer splatter in the bowl.
Con: The tall, narrow shape makes folding airy batters and pouring out contents harder.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. Some candidates were set aside.
Essential · $91GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickOther well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
EssentialScraping bowls clean with mini sizes
Essential · Get It
Ten tools, mostly silicone heat-proof to 550 degrees F, including a ladle, whisk, peeler, two spoons and five spatulas. The spatulas scraped bowls clean, and the mini sizes handled small batches in tight spaces. The whole set is dishwasher safe and held up through a year of regular use.
Pro: Ten tools including three spatula sizes for folding, small-batch mixing and scraping corners.
Con: The set does not include a pair of tongs.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. Other well-backed products sit too close to the chosen ones to be a separate level.
Essential · $17Good
Absolute · $40BestEssentialMedium cans in eight to ten cranks
UpgradeSide-cut lids with smooth edges
AbsoluteCrank-free opening leaves smooth edges
Essential · OXO Good
This is a classic manual rotary opener with wide, cushioned, nonslip handles and an oversized knob. Reviewers found it bites in cleanly and turns smoothly, opening medium cans in about eight to ten cranks. It has a built-in bottle opener and survived two drops onto concrete without damage.
Pro: A manual rotary can opener with cushioned nonslip handles and a built-in bottle opener.
Con: It cuts from the top, leaving a sharp, jagged lid edge, and needs handwashing.
Upgrade · Kuhn Rikon
This safety opener cuts around the side of the can, so the lid edges are smooth and will not cut fingers. Its long knob sits on top of the can, so either hand can turn it, and it gives good leverage. A side button works small pliers that lift the lid off without touching it.
Pro: Side-cut lids with smooth edges instead of sharp ones.
Con: Its plastic button and knob may not hold up, and there is a learning curve.
Absolute · Hamilton Beach
This plug-in electric opener clamps the lid's lip between two gears and cuts through the side, leaving smooth edges. You lock the can in place and hold down a lever, and it opened cans in about 8 to 11 seconds. It opened 28-ounce cans without tipping over, though it takes up counter space.
Pro: Electric, crank-free opening that still leaves smooth edges.
Con: It has no auto shut-off, and running past one turn can leave metal slivers.
Essential · $20GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickSome candidates were set aside.
EssentialHard cheese and vegetables
Essential · Cuisipro 4-Sided
This mostly stainless steel box grater has four sides: coarse and medium holes, fine holes for zesting, and a slicer. Its sharp etched teeth handle hard and soft cheeses, carrots and potatoes with little effort. It has etched measurements on the side and a removable base.
Pro: A very sharp stainless steel box grater with four sides that all work well.
Con: It has few extras, and the ginger-grating surface on its base felt like an afterthought.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. Some candidates were set aside.
Essential · $24GoodNo Upgrade pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pickNo product at this level has enough backing.
EssentialTiny holes drain fast
Essential · Bellemain Micro-Perforated
A 5-quart stainless steel colander on a tall metal ring base that lifts the bowl above the sink. Its many tiny holes drain fast without clogging and hold small foods like orzo. The wide handles stay cool after boiling water, and it is dishwasher-safe. It is light but sturdy and did not dent in durability tests.
Pro: A stainless steel footed colander whose tiny holes drain fast and keep orzo in.
Con: Bulky to store, and a few food bits got stuck under its rim.
No Upgrade pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Absolute pick. No product at this level has enough backing.
No Upgrade pick
EssentialAcidic ingredients and dishwasher cycles
AbsolutePlastic tabs on handle ends
Essential · OXO Good Grips
Four stainless steel cups snap together with magnets, so the set stays tidy in a drawer. One cup can come off without disturbing the rest, and the markings survive the dishwasher. Only four cups, so a 1/8 cup needs a workaround or a precision scale.
No Upgrade pick.
Absolute · Norpro Grip-Ez
Five cups, from one-eighth to one cup, cover a wide measuring range in one stainless-steel set. Handles sit flush with the rims, which keeps leveling each cup off simple, and the set is accurate. Plastic tabs on the handle ends make these easier to hold than many other stainless-steel models. Handles bend a bit when scooped into wet sand, and some find the set feels unbalanced.
No Upgrade pick
EssentialSlim oval bowls for sticky food
AbsoluteSturdy handles and center curve
Essential · Cuisipro Measuring Spoon Set
Five oval spoons, in stainless steel, run from an eighth teaspoon to one tablespoon. Slim bowls fit most narrow containers, and a rounded shape lets sticky ingredients release. Half and full teaspoon measure exactly right, and each spoon rests level on the countertop. Handles are short, so reaching the bottom of taller containers takes more effort.
No Upgrade pick.
Absolute · Sur La Table NA0004
Six stainless steel spoons with slim rectangular bowls, and the set is dishwasher-safe. Measures very accurately, and its slim bowls fit through most standard spice jars with a 1.25-inch opening. Sturdy handles reach the bottom of containers when needed, and a center curve makes them very difficult to bend. The matte finish releases ingredients less easily than polished steel, a trade-off worth weighing.










